Lifestyle

BBC denies atheist traditional Thought for Day slot

Valerie Horton

THE BBC broke with tradition yesterday by allowing an atheist to present an alternative 'Thought for the Day' on the Radio 4 Today programme at the behest of guest editor Sir Tim Berners-Lee.

But the broadcaster denied atheist minister Reverend Andy Pakula the opportunity to speak in the usual "God slot" at 7.45am, and put him on air an hour earlier.

Reverend Jim Corrigall, from Suffolk, gave a second message at the traditional point in the programme schedule.

Both ministers, like Sir Tim, are members of the diverse Unitarian Church, which includes members of various religions and "non-theists" such as Rev Pakula.

The atheist minister told The Independent that he had been invited by the founder of the world wide web to present the main Thought for the Day but had been blocked by BBC management.

"It's almost as if they are afraid that if they let me do it, they will have to let [Richard] Dawkins do it," he said.

The BBC has come under repeated pressure to allow non-believers to contribute to Thought for the Day, which was introduced in 1970.

Introducing Rev Pakula, Today presenter Mishal Husain told Boxing Day listeners: "One of the contributions Sir Tim Berners-Lee wanted to make to this programme was to have an atheist deliver Thought for the Day, something that was not possible because it is part of the BBC's religious programming and is a reflection by speakers from the perspective of their faith. However, we do have an alternative Thought for the Day this morning."

In his address, Rev Pakula said: "As an atheist, I don't believe that there is an omnipotent other who will intervene in earthly life to save us from natural dangers or to save us from our own worst impulses."

But he also expressed the view that there was nothing contradictory in being an atheist and celebrating Christmas, telling the audience that his London congregation had held a Christmas Eve service and sung carols.

"While I don't literally believe the stories underlying Christmas, I do very much believe in its most important messages," he said.

In discussion with Ms Husain afterwards, the atheist minister took the opportunity to question the BBC's procedures on Thought for the Day as he suggested that the meaning of "terms such as religion and faith" were increasingly unclear.

"The BBC talks about not allowing people of 'no faith' to present Thought for the Day, well, what does 'no faith' mean? Here I am, I'm a Minister of Religion, leading a congregation talking about peace and love and I'm considered a person of no faith because I say I'm an atheist," he said.

Following previous debate over the slot, the BBC's head of religion and ethics Aaqil Ahmed held a review but concluded in September that Today should "continue as was". He said: "It is a specific slot within the Today programme which is a reflection from a religious perspective on stories of importance in the news."

During his address at 7.45am, theist Unitarian minister Rev Corrigall spoke of his church's support for gay marriage.

Topics:  bbc religion



Things to do this weekend

AND THEY'RE OFF: Don't miss the action at Bundamba Racecourse today.

What's on in Ipswich

COMMENT: Phone scams on the rise

We're keen to hear from anyone who received a suspicious call

Join in the fun as MKR finalists cook up storm

Valerie and Courtney will be at the Heart and Soul Festival this weekend.

There will also be 80 stallholders and a range of food trucks

Local Partners

RECIPE: Cream of the breakfast crop

A little patience will produce some sensational porridge.

RECIPE: No risking it with this biscuit

These delicious almond biscuits are perfect for a morning tea treat.

Perfect for morning tea or a Christmas gift

Beer drinkers are getting fruity fresh for summer

ON TAP: Pumpyard chef Garth Kelly and Corinne Browne test out the new Lime Lager.

Ipswich brewery whips up Lime Lager in time for scorcher weekend

Family reunited with stolen puppy after police seized it

Ashlee Wright with her family Dexter, Amily, Tate after they were reunited with their dog Tully who was found by police in someone's home.

Family reunited with beloved pet dog stolen from their backyard

Fashion: Jump aboard the relaxed marina vibe

Look 1

Saily away with me this fashion season

OPINION: Taking a holiday is damn hard work

Greg Bray, columnist for the Gladstone Observer. Photo Brenda Strong/The Observer

On A Lighter Note with Greg Bray

How and when do you tell your children about death?

Listen to your gut and do what is best for your family when considering discussing death with young children.

How much do children need to know about death?