Katie Pladl, 20, cuddles her son Bennett with her biological father Steven Pladl, 45. Picture: Instagram
Katie Pladl, 20, cuddles her son Bennett with her biological father Steven Pladl, 45. Picture: Instagram

Shock end to twisted incest case

AN incestuous father who had a baby with his daughter is believed to have murdered the infant before killing the young woman, her adoptive father and then himself.

Police in three US states are now scrambling to piece together the circumstances leading up to the terrible tragedy.

Local authorities said Steven Walter Pladl, 43, was found dead in New York at around 9am on Thursday.

The bodies of Katie Pladl, 20, and her adoptive father Anthony Fusco, 56, were discovered in Connecticut a short time later.

Officers found the lifeless body of the Pladl's seven-month-old son Bennett in the North Carolina home they shared just after 9am.

The tragedy comes just two months after Steven and Katie Pladl were charged with incest after authorities learned they had married with a newborn child in a case that made world headlines.

Steven Pladl, 45 (right), married his biological daughter Katie, 20 (left) months before she gave birth to their son Bennett. Picture: Supplied
Steven Pladl, 45 (right), married his biological daughter Katie, 20 (left) months before she gave birth to their son Bennett. Picture: Supplied

Steven Pladl's mother called 911 to ask for a welfare check on Bennett after her son told her in a phonecall that he had killed the boy, according to WTVR.

Police say Pladl's mother had custody of the child, and that he picked up the baby from her Wednesday night.

"My son just called me and, ah, he told me he ... oh my God. He killed his baby and he's in the house," the distressed woman can be heard telling the dispatcher.

Katie and her father Steven Pladl pictured in 2016, after Katie tracked her birth parents down via social media. Picture: Instagram
Katie and her father Steven Pladl pictured in 2016, after Katie tracked her birth parents down via social media. Picture: Instagram

"His wife broke up with him yesterday over the phone. She's in New York and he told me he was on his way and after bringing the baby to her and then he was coming back."

The woman states her son then revealed he had killed Bennett, Katie and her adoptive father.

"He left the baby dead," she tells the dispatcher. "He told me to call the police and I shouldn't go over there. He killed his wife. He killed his father and I can't even believe this is happening."

Steven Pladl and his heavily pregnant daughter Katie, flanked by her adoptive father Anthony Fusco and his wife, and Pladl’s mother (left) at their wedding last June. Picture: Instagram
Steven Pladl and his heavily pregnant daughter Katie, flanked by her adoptive father Anthony Fusco and his wife, and Pladl’s mother (left) at their wedding last June. Picture: Instagram

Pladl married his daughter Katie last July while she was heavily pregnant with their child in a secret ceremony.

Pladl and Katie's birth mother Alyssa had given her up for adoption shortly after she was born in 1998.

The three were reunited in June 2016 after Katie tracked them down via social media. Within months, Pladl separated from Alyssa and began a sexual relationship with Katie.

Pladl and Katie were arrested in January this year after Alyssa read the diary of her 11-year-old daughter, who had documented her sister's affair with their father, even drawing pictures of Katie pregnant with an arrow pointing to the "demon" inside.

Father and daughter were each charged with incest, adultery, and contributing to delinquency and their mugshots splashed across international media in a case that shocked the world.

But their relationship imploded this week when Katie, who was living with her adoptive parents, the Fuscos, in New York as per her bail conditions, broke up with her father in a phonecall.

Investigators believe it was that phonecall that set Pladl off on a killing spree.

Katie poses in a picture with her biological mother Alyssa and her younger sisters. The sister on the right, 11, is the one that documented Katie’s affair with their father in her diary. Picture:
Katie poses in a picture with her biological mother Alyssa and her younger sisters. The sister on the right, 11, is the one that documented Katie’s affair with their father in her diary. Picture:

Knightdale Police Chief Lawrence Capps told reporters Pladl killed his son after picking him up from his mother's house in Cary, North Carolina on Wednesday night.

He then drove almost 1000km to New Milford, Connecticut and shot dead Katie and Anthony Fusco as they sat in a ute, before making his way across the state line and killing himself.

Officers searching for a van with North Carolina plates that witnesses had linked to the double shooting found it just over the New York State line in Dover about eight km away.

When police approached the still-running vehicle, they found Pladl dead at the wheel, police told the Hartford Courant.

This morning, Pladl's lawyer Rick Friedman said there was no way authorities could have known he would go on a killing spree if released on bail.

"This is a terrible tragedy that nobody foresaw. I really believe that if the judges or the prosecutor or the defence attorneys in this case had any clue that the minor child or anyone would be harmed there would not be a bond set for any of the parties," he told WNCN.

"This is a tragedy for everyone involved. We are all heartbroken."

Steven Pladl, 45, with his baby son Bennett, the child he had with his biological daughter Katie. Picture: Instagram
Steven Pladl, 45, with his baby son Bennett, the child he had with his biological daughter Katie. Picture: Instagram

 

 

TIMELINE

1998: Katie Pladl born to Steven and Alyssa Pladl and legally adopted to the Fusco family of New York.

2016: Katie Pladl turns 18 and uses social media to find biological parents

Aug 2016: Katie Pladl moves in with Steven Pladl and her biological mother near Richmond, Virginia

Nov 2016: Steven Pladl and wife legally separate; wife moves out

May 23, 2017: Steven Pladl's wife reads child's diary that says Katie is pregnant with Steven's child

May 31, 2017: Authorities interview Steven Pladl's two other children

June 2017: Steven and Katie Pladl move to a home Knightdale, North Carolina

July 2017: Steven and Katie Pladl marry

Sept 2017: Katie Pladl gives birth to Steven's child, warrants say

Nov 29, 2017: Henrico County police issue arrest warrants for Steven and Katie Pladl

Jan 27, 2018: Steven and Katie Pladl are arrested at their Knightdale home

April 11, 2018: Steven Pladl picks up child from his mother's home in Cary, North Carolina

April 12, 2018 at 8:40am: Steven Pladl is found dead in Wingdale, New York. Katie Pladl and her adoptive father are found dead in New Milford, Connecticut

April 12, 2018 at 9am: Steven Pladl's mother calls for a welfare check for her son's Knightdale home. Seven-month-old Bennett is found dead in the home.

 

If you or someone you know needs help, please contact Lifeline on 13 11 14

 

Father and daughter Steven and Katie Pladl on their wedding day last year. Picture: Instagram
Father and daughter Steven and Katie Pladl on their wedding day last year. Picture: Instagram
Katie gave birth to her father’s child, Bennett, in September last year. Picture: Instagram
Katie gave birth to her father’s child, Bennett, in September last year. Picture: Instagram
Steven Pladl dries Bennett, his son with biological daughter Katie, after bathing him. Picture: Instagram
Steven Pladl dries Bennett, his son with biological daughter Katie, after bathing him. Picture: Instagram
Katie’s 11-year-old sister drew their father Steven as ‘Satan’ and the baby inside her pregnant sister’s belly as a ‘demon’. Picture: Supplied
Katie’s 11-year-old sister drew their father Steven as ‘Satan’ and the baby inside her pregnant sister’s belly as a ‘demon’. Picture: Supplied
Steven’s affair with Katie was exposed after Katie’s biological mother read her 11-year-old daughter’s diary and reported them to police. Picture: Supplied
Steven’s affair with Katie was exposed after Katie’s biological mother read her 11-year-old daughter’s diary and reported them to police. Picture: Supplied
Alyssa Pladl reported her husband and daughter to police after discovering their incestuous affair documented in her 11-year-old daughter’s diary. Picture: Supplied
Alyssa Pladl reported her husband and daughter to police after discovering their incestuous affair documented in her 11-year-old daughter’s diary. Picture: Supplied


'I wasn't dishonest about it': Driver's take on fuel theft

premium_icon 'I wasn't dishonest about it': Driver's take on fuel theft

Conscientious worker wasn't dishonest about stealing fuel

Antoniolli's assets stripped after suspension from council

premium_icon Antoniolli's assets stripped after suspension from council

The mayor has been "formally relieved of any official duties"

Dump operators to reveal plans for proposed changes

Dump operators to reveal plans for proposed changes

Dump company planning to change its Ipswich operations

Local Partners