Election 2010: the week that was | Federal Election 2010

Federal Election 2010

Election 2010: the week that was

DOES it matter if a prime minister is childless? Ringless? Godless? No. Clueless? Yes.
AAP Images

Poll

Who is your preferred Prime Minister?

This poll ended on 05 September 2010.

Julia Gillard

27%

Tony Abbott

49%

Bob Brown

5%

None of the above

8%

Bring back Kevin Rudd

9%

This is not a scientific poll. The results reflect only the opinions of those who chose to participate.

Poll

Who will you be voting for in the federal election?

This poll ended on 05 September 2010.

Labor

27%

Liberals

43%

National Party

8%

Greens

12%

Family First

1%

Independent

2%

Other

3%

This is not a scientific poll. The results reflect only the opinions of those who chose to participate.

OPINION:  DOES it matter if a prime minister is childless? Ringless? Godless? No.

Clueless? Yes.

Julia Gillard is far from clueless, so there all of these matters should rest.

But they probably won't.

The novelty value of Australia's first boy-versus-girl federal election campaign is one thing, but the preoccupation with it is another.

The quicker we get over it and move on - sorry, move forward - the better.

Gender could well have become a campaign issue this week, but it didn't, thanks to Gillard's decision to show herself as a human being rather than a political robot.

A cabinet leak can be very damaging to a childless career woman with a live-in boyfriend if it shows she argued against the generosity of a paid parental leave scheme and a pension rise.

It could have painted her as family-unfriendly, especially at a time when her opponent Tony Abbott was bobbing up here and there displaying things Gillard doesn't have, namely a spouse and children.

It could have portrayed the Labor leader as selfish and heartless - "deliberately barren" was a phrase coalition backbencher Bill Heffernan once used in a notoriously cruel, unfair and irrelevant insult.

But Gillard threw away the script and got passionate.

In doing so she looked more of a leader than all the spin doctors between them had made her look previously.

Of course she closely questioned the cost of measures that were going to chew up $50 billion in the next decade, she said; that was her job.

But she did not oppose them.

In terms of personal damage to her, the issue was defused, though it cropped up again when former Labor leader Mark Latham accused Gillard's predecessor Kevin Rudd of being the leaker.

One newspaper, Sydney's Daily Telegraph, digitally aged Gillard on its front page, giving her grey hair and wrinkles alongside a story saying Australia's grey army was angry over her opposition to a $30 pension rise on the grounds that "old people never vote for us".

But the image jarred and missed the mark.

Gillard, meanwhile, was looking far more glamorous in a 13-page cover story and photo shoot for the Australian Women's Weekly.

She engendered empathy by explaining to the magazine's two million readers how she was comfortable with her choice not to have children, but also felt "wistful about what could have been".

"I suppose I had to recognise that this is not a life of infinite possibilities - that at some point you run out of possibilities and your choices have all added up to one fundamental life choice," she said.

She spoke of the "exquisite irony" of childlessness being seen as a political vulnerability, yet said if a mother with three kids under 10 presented as a prime minister, people would say: "How on earth is she going to give the job the focus it's going to need?"

Out on the campaign trail, Gillard was asked if she and boyfriend Tim Mathieson were going to get married.

All sweetness and reason, she said that apart from that being a personal matter, it was not something one person could decide alone.

Voters have no doubt forgotten, because it was so plain boring, that the week started with the televised leaders debate in which Tony Abbott said: "My wife Margie and I know what it's like to raise a family, to wrestle with a big mortgage, with grocery bills, with school fees."

If it was an attempt to differentiate the two competing brands by contrasting personal life styles and life choices, to turn Gillard's perceived advantage of femininity against her, it failed.

The TV worm - or worms, for this time there were male and female wrigglers - scored it to Gillard, although on the count of "fair dinkums" used, Abbott won eight to four.

But more Australians watched two guys cooking off in the MasterChef final, which says a fair bit about politics.

So what did Australians learn this week?

Not much, apart from the compelling fact that Gillard is to ear lobes what Abbott is to ears, that she will be the first PM to live in The Lodge in a de facto relationship if she wins on August 21, and that she's not so hypocritical as to pretend a faith in God that she doesn't feel.

The really big campaign news was what didn't happen to inflation.

The government got the best figure in three years, meaning there's suddenly little prospect of a mid-campaign interest rate rise next week, one of the factors which helped sink John Howard three years ago.

In short, Gillard received terrific economic news, she dodged the one bullet that was fired, which came from within her own ranks rather than the opposition's, Abbott failed to land a punch or gain any real traction, and every time that happens is a week lost.

It was a neutral week, which means it went to the incumbent, Gillard.

 
© AAP

Add a Comment

 

Recent Comments

Add a Comment »

Posted by curiouscat from Basin Pocket, Queensland

30 July 2010 3:47 p.m. | Suggest removal » | Post reply »

At last an artical that makes sense...well done and well said !

Posted by b4ref33t from Bli Bli, Queensland

30 July 2010 4 p.m. | Suggest removal » | Post reply »

"thanks to Gillard's decision to show herself as a human being rather than a political robot."

Wow, given this is supposedly 'news' reporting rather than an opinion piece, I feel it's fair to call it as it is.

Are you serious?, or do you consider being muzzled by faceless people being 'passionate' and measures up to the standard of 'humanity'? any human, even a real scoundrel of one, would want to set the record straight, particularly for the kinds of record being set.

This story, in its context is no pure political spin, and probably comes out of the same factory that has been dishing out the spin our prime minister has had to perpetuate, except the later is spin with a fair bit of muzzle.

Posted by SilverRidge from Blanchview, Queensland

30 July 2010 4:49 p.m. | Suggest removal » | Post reply »

This article is a disgrace if it is meant to be a news piece based on facts. It must surely be written by a labour hack?

Posted by Kevin_Thomas from Ipswich & Region, Queensland

31 July 2010 10:11 a.m. | Suggest removal » | Post reply »

A completely one sided story from a Labor ogre. The person who wrote this any many other media people will paint this woman in a bright light and we will have her ruin the country as Blighe has done in Qld. At least try to be impartial, this story is a disgrace.

Ed. note: The article is an opinion column by Doug Conway, Senior Correspondent with AAP.

Posted by AndyMac from Grafton, New South Wales

31 July 2010 11:19 a.m. | Suggest removal » | Post reply »

I am not voting for a caretaker Labor Prime Minister that stabbed in the back the PM that we voted for. The Gang of Four and the faceless men of Labor NSW, Vic and SA. What guarantees do we have that these men will not do the same thing again if they do not like any Labor PM. Just like they have done in NSW over 15 years and destroyed NSW into a third world state. The Nth Coast is a disaster area after 15 years of NSW Labor and Federal Labor have no long term plans for the Nth Coast. The Greens have destroyed employment and are giving all their preferences to Labor.

Posted by ChrisNorman from Agnes Waters, Queensland

31 July 2010 12:50 p.m. | Suggest removal » | Post reply »

AndyMac from Grafton who did Abbott stab to get in
Who did Turnball stab to get in?
Who didn't Costello have the guts to stab and never got a chance?
If Abbott wins, don't think Turnball is going to sit in the back bench without sharpening his knife.
The LNP had over a decade and did nothing for the skills shortage ,the ageing population,pensioners pay,lack of superannuation,the environment or infrastructure investment.
They then introduced Work Choices which made the lives of the majority of Australians a lot worse than they were before.

Posted by alwayswatching from Grafton, New South Wales

31 July 2010 2:12 p.m. | Suggest removal » | Post reply »

What trash, look at the polls its now 50/50 and given where they were a year ago and even after the night of the long knives, the Labout vote is dwindling.

She has been out bid on paid maternity leave, been out bid on aid to the disabled, aout bid on the boat pepole, and and is only offering bits of of add ons to pre-existing policies.

The claim to have saved Australia in the GFC what ROT, they were given a firm solid base to stand on, and they blew it away, lets HOPE and second burst of the GFC doesn't hit then we WILL suffer more, Borrowing $100m a DAY is NOT good business.

I don't care if she is childless, and living in a defacto relationship, or a women, I can look past that and look at the policies. Mining tax is still a tax and backdown, The boat people fix wasn't, and well the ETS well that now not up to her but the 150 community group, so her three big fixes she tried to fix before the election we not anything really.

time to go.

Posted by AndyMac from Grafton, New South Wales

31 July 2010 2:54 p.m. | Suggest removal » | Post reply »

ChrisNorman. HELLO, The Liberals did not stab Turnbull in the back. It was a democratic vote by the party to replace Turnbull and there where three people that put up their hand for the job.. It is now fact that Rudd was stabbed in the back by the Faceless men in NSW, Vic and SA. It had nothing to do with the Federal Labor Party. it was all done under the cover of darkness and behind closed doors at night when none of the Labor Party in Canberra where present. This is not democracy it is the dirty tactics of the Labor party that even Falkener has gone public on in a public forum. I will nto vote for a Labor party that stabbed the voted Labor PM in the back, the public put in? Or are you living on some other planet?

Posted by AndyMac from Grafton, New South Wales

31 July 2010 3:06 p.m. | Suggest removal » | Post reply »

We are now $90B in debt and borrowing at the rate of $100m/week and as "alwayswatching" has listed some of the disaster that the Gang of Four have had their grubby hands in. There is one big issue that Gillard has refused to talk about during this campaign and is her disaster and that is the BER program that has wasted $4B and built tin sheds and small toilet blocks as class rooms, extremely poor out comes by the NSW Labor and the rhorting by the building companies and unions of our tax payers money. They have duded their own children and the future of our next generation.

Posted by kathyfrost from Alexandra Headland, Queensland

31 July 2010 5:17 p.m. | Suggest removal » | Post reply »

Andy Mac,

fran bailey was missing from the vote which went on only one. There has never been any explanation for her absence. It was party room thuggery against a popular encumbent. Same as Rudd.

Your "big issue" is one of the reasons we don't have a recession, or do you deny even that?

This is just rabid & ill informed Labor bashing aimed to deflect debate from what a nightmare it will be if Mr Rabbott gets his hand on any power.

Won't be long before abortion and workchoices are on the agenda. Religous education mandatory in Government schools. The Queen back on all our walls. So much for individual rights......

Posted by Predictor from Moore Park, Queensland

31 July 2010 8:16 p.m. | Suggest removal » | Post reply »

I made a predicting cartoon on 11th. March 2010 that shows Kevin Rudd's pump-up suit deflating.
Hot air blowing out the valves shrinking his suit to the floor, rolling up his ALP emblem tie and exposing skinny Kevin Rudd's Skeleton. Lot's of my friends and follower have seen this predicting carton which was spot on in all details prior the happenings.
Well Julia Gillard's carton shows her joining the dole que behind the Spanish Matadors with the wounded bull.
Good by Julia..!
Labor party is dead like the Spanish bullfight..!
NO MORE EVER AGAIN..!
FINISH..!

Posted by CaroBird from Upper Kedron, Queensland

01 August 2010 5:37 p.m. | Suggest removal » | Post reply »

How did our PM dodge a bullet? Labor is leaking badly. The problem is not that Julia questioned parental leave and $30 rise to pensioners. The problem is the reason why she questioned the rise? "Pensioners don't vote Labor anyhow". I see her in a different light now. Labor stuffs up the economy every time and we have nothing to show for it. The Asian Crisis was worse for Auz than the GFC and we didn't need the big debt. PM Abbot sounds good to me now.

Posted by jcgorman from Grasstree Beach, Queensland

02 August 2010 7:57 a.m. | Suggest removal » | Post reply »

People,
HELLO,Its just party polictics and both sides can be just as ruthless.
If you havent got the numbers,or know someone who has, you dont get the gig.
The 'Gillard faction' put Rudd up there & they won Govt...Rudd seemed to forget that,getting too obsessed in his own agenda.
Gillard has done the honourable thing getting us to an election quickly.
Cast your vote...

Posted by ChrisNorman from Agnes Waters, Queensland

02 August 2010 8:15 a.m. | Suggest removal » | Post reply »

LNP was in power for a decade and gave pensioners nothing,except kerosene baths,Labour gave them a $30 rise almost immediately.

If Labor stuffs the economy, why according to the OECD, Australia is currently one of the healthiest countries, economically, throughout the world.?

Google that and educate yourself.

Posted by RobertofGoodna from Goodna, Queensland

02 August 2010 9:28 a.m. | Suggest removal » | Post reply »

Hasn't anyone considered that the sustained attack on Julia Gillard is coming from a group of Religious Extremists, probably from all Parties?

Posted by boomer from Flinders View, Queensland

02 August 2010 10:52 a.m. | Suggest removal » | Post reply »

Julia Gillard states that she will reveal her true personality, this is probably part of the theatrics. How can anyone really know what she stands for when she is acting all the time.

Posted by alwayswatching from Grafton, New South Wales

02 August 2010 11:02 a.m. | Suggest removal » | Post reply »

Chris,

Don't forget Julia opposed the pension rise because the pensioners didn't vote labour!!! and the $30 has been swollowed up as quickly as it was given.

Labour Has stuffed the economy as they had $20b+ in the bank when they took over and within months it had all gone and $40b debt took its place. If the $20b wasn't ther ti be spent I doubt we would have survived the way we have. so don't give Labour the credit for something they were given not earned.

What have they earned? a huge debt, $100b a week+ interest debt, hit the miners with a tax so they can look good, promise a ETS to fix the greatest moral dilema of our time and deliver a 150 community based think tank, BER thats under-delivers and over-priced, Pink bats that cost lives and millions in potential legal actions, A boat people fix that wasn't.

And now she wants us to see the real Julia, what does that mean? what we have seen ISN'T her? was she the stage managed puppet of the unions? so the polls show she is loosing ground so has to change tact. Also today she has unleashed the last card in her pack, get personal, Mr Abbott is fair game she says, well thats great isn't it, play the man NOT the ball, offer nothing but smear, the cupboard must be bare?? and we still have 3 weeks to go???

Posted by Onewhatknows from Murwillumbah, New South Wales

02 August 2010 11:06 a.m. | Suggest removal » | Post reply »

Is this Julias version of " I am not anybodies pupet"?

this will make sense to nsw readers anyway.

looking forward to seeing jules throwing the switch

Posted by mihughes from Grafton, New South Wales

02 August 2010 11:31 a.m. | Suggest removal » | Post reply »

If julia can't control her own party even if it is from
Religious extremists as RobetofGoonda proposes how is she going to operate a government?

She needs to find these people that are attacking her in her own party and put an end to them.

The problem with the Labor party is that it has many one timers in it and they all want to hold their acquired through Poor Final term choices by John Howard and the might of the media machine that was Kevin 07. As such they have no loyalty to their leader but only to their own pockets which will take a hit if they don't have the correct person in, Labor candidates are campaigning without referencing Labor or Gillard in an effort to get people to vote for them and not the party they are part of.

Posted by Tweedguy1 from Tweed Heads South, New South Wales

02 August 2010 12:08 p.m. | Suggest removal » | Post reply »

In response to Chris Norman and some others who claim that the pensioners got nothing under the coalition and plenty under Gillard....
Chris ACOSS has stated in the report reviewing the May 2009 budget that gave the increase of $33 that "Over the last decade, pensions rose by 20% in real terms"..This is also backed up by the FaHSCIA website where it can be seen that pensions are around $2000 higher now than what they would have been under the prefered labor methods of indexing the pension against CPI or ALCI....Along with this most of us that will rely on Super for future incomes instead of a pension we will now have less due to diminished earnings from blue chip investments such as BHP and RIO as they are paying an extra 30% tax on there profits...I dont even dare start on the impact state labor Govt's have had incuding the many freinds I have in QLD health that still have not been paid for months of work!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted by RobertofGoodna from Goodna, Queensland

02 August 2010 12:37 p.m. | Suggest removal » | Post reply »

The comments on this site at least have come from some thought. Give Gillard a Go! She was suddenly thrust into the Leadership of a great country. Give her time to "feel her way around". No-one knows how a new leader will perform until she is given the reins.

So far, she has my vote! She is an intelligent person who understands how to be cautious. What better leader could a nation have?

Posted by RobertofGoodna from Goodna, Queensland

02 August 2010 12:51 p.m. | Suggest removal » | Post reply »

Mihughes of Grafton, you are so right! Where are the men or women of PRINCIPLE in either of the major Parties? Where is a Chifley or a Menzies? Or even a Fraser or a Hawke? The choice is clear, do we want an intellectual or a clown as our Prime Minister?

Posted by RobertofGoodna from Goodna, Queensland

02 August 2010 1:03 p.m. | Suggest removal » | Post reply »

Tweedguy1, you leave our honourable State politicians alone. It wasn't their fault that Dept of Health employees wern't paid. It was God's will!!

Posted by Tweedguy1 from Tweed Heads South, New South Wales

02 August 2010 1:21 p.m. | Suggest removal » | Post reply »

RobertofGoodna,

Your kidding arn't you!! How could you say this when whe was deputy PM for 3 years and continually assured Kevin Rudd she was behind him 100%...Well she certainly was behind him...with a great big knife ready to stick into his back as soon as she got the chance....all she needed was a little shove from the union buddy power brokers in the labor party...I voted Kev07 but after 3 years of federal labour failures and 15 years of NSW and QLD labor failures I don't think Julia deserves my vote....

Posted by Tweedguy1 from Tweed Heads South, New South Wales

02 August 2010 2:35 p.m. | Suggest removal » | Post reply »

Oh RobertofGoodna, now we see just how valid your comments are when you excuse the qld govt for a significant and obviouse stuff up and blame of all things Gods will....go tell that to the 4 nurses I know personally that have either not been paid at all for months or are still owed substantial amounts by QLD Health....which is a QLD Gov't run body............

Are you going to back the QLD govt over the hard working nurses and doctors???

Posted by alwayswatching from Grafton, New South Wales

02 August 2010 3:29 p.m. | Suggest removal » | Post reply »

Do we want a interlectual or a clown? is asked , clowns have red hair don't they????

Latest polls have the clown 50/50 !!

Am not willing to give her a go just because she has been in charge for just a few weeks, she has been in charge for three years as part of the gang of 4, she is not new nor been thrust into the job she WANTED it and took it.

Posted by RobertofGoodna from Goodna, Queensland

02 August 2010 8:03 p.m. | Suggest removal » | Post reply »

Oh Tweedyguy1, do you not recognise satire so thickly laid on? The QLD Health debacle had nothing to do with politicians, but with the deficient public servants they appointed. As a retired IT manager, I am utterly appalled at this issue. Muslims would say "If it happened then it was written." Christians would wring their hands and say "It must have been God's will."

Posted by RobertofGoodna from Goodna, Queensland

02 August 2010 8:11 p.m. | Suggest removal » | Post reply »

Wake up, electors! The choice is between a highly intelligent female and a male buffoon. Even so, many rednecks would prefer the buffoon, simply because he is male.

Posted by RobertofGoodna from Goodna, Queensland

02 August 2010 8:23 p.m. | Suggest removal » | Post reply »

AndyMac, the facts are that Turnbull was ousted by one single vote, when two members were not present.
Fraudulent election of Abbott?
Kevin Rudd stood down when he was shown that the numbers were against him.
Party Politics is simply a numbers game.

Posted by Tweedguy1 from Tweed Heads South, New South Wales

03 August 2010 9:47 a.m. | Suggest removal » | Post reply »

RobertofGoodna, by the sounds of it there are no issues or debacles that politicians are at fault for (so long as there Labor). One wonders what your reaction would have been if a coalition Govt was in at the tme. Ex IT manager you may be but you must also realise that like in big business (which Government realy is) the buck stops with the boss and in this case that is the government in charge that has been responsible for implementing these monumental stuff ups...

Posted by RobertofGoodna from Goodna, Queensland

04 August 2010 10:19 a.m. | Suggest removal » | Post reply »

Tweedyguy, there are so many issues here. I. We Canetoads do not operate within the Westminster System, where a Minister has responsibility, and there is a House of Review. Would you like us to back to the Joh days and the infamous "Special Branch"?
How can anyone seriously consider having a Prime Minister who admits to having to go to a Jesuit priest in order to find out what he should think about an issue? Bring back a Menzies or a Fraser, with Black Jack McEwan or Doug Anthony, and I might vote for the LNP.

Posted by RobertofGoodna from Goodna, Queensland

04 August 2010 3:34 p.m. | Suggest removal » | Post reply »

What a circus! Cognoscere primum rerum. (First of all, get your facts straight.) How fickle we are. Has Abbott's disgraceful conduct in pursuing Pauline Hanson been forgotten? A vengeful extremist religious lunatic?
This election should have been between Rudd and Turnbull.
Both major parties ruined that.
Let's go for honesty and truth: INDEPENDENT.

Posted by RobertofGoodna from Goodna, Queensland

04 August 2010 3:43 p.m. | Suggest removal » | Post reply »

Alwayswatching from Grafton, Abbott has spent his whole political life smearing others with his religiously-inspired hatred. He has no answer to Gillard. So he is terrified of an open debate.

Add a Comment

 
  • Mostly cloudy

    Today

    Mostly cloudy

    8°C/25°C
  • Possible shower

    Tomorrow

    Possible shower

    10°C/25°C

Ipswich forecast »

Special offers
Virgo

24 August - 23 September

You're able to strike up a new friendship now, and one in particular that can last well into the future. Perhaps you're a little guarded and mistrusting but don't... More Horoscopes »

Select your zodiac sign

Aries | Taurus | Gemini | Cancer | Leo | Virgo | Libra | Scorpio | Sagittarius | Capricorn | Aquarius | Pisces

What's On

Browse

 

powered by

Link to top
APN news and media

© APN News & Media Ltd 2010. Unauthorised reproduction is prohibited under the laws of Australia and by international treaty. APN | APN Group Websites

Back to access links