News

Justice refuses probe into murder trial jurors

A SUPREME Court justice, who feared the time-honoured jury system would be in jeopardy, has refused to allow lawyers to probe jurors involved in a Rockhampton murder trial.

Justice Roslyn Atkinson was asked to consider whether she should allow a Queensland sheriff to put questions to jurors involved in convicting three men of the death of Robert James Buckley at the old Etna Creek Prison.

Justice Atkinson, during the application in Brisbane Supreme Court, said the legislation giving her discretion to make the order was born after the now infamous Joh Bjelke-Petersen jury saga.

Mark Dempsey Knight, Wesley Robert Williams and Wayne Thomas Robertson were found guilty after a trial in April of murdering the 23-year-old in 1999.

Buckley was found dead, hanging by a towel from a window in a shower block at the prison.

It was the second trial the men had faced, after the Court of Appeal set aside initial guilty verdicts and ordered a retrial.

The court heard during the application that a juror had commented to his barber that the men were serving life sentences or long-term jail terms anyway so the jury's verdicts made no difference.

The barber served a lawyer for one of the accused men later that same day and passed on the conversation.

The trio's lawyers argued the comment meant the juror could have read newspaper articles "already in the public arena" during the trial and had therefore performed illegal "external" investigations while he was on jury duty.

He said jurors could be approached under section 70 (7) of the Jury Act if the court suspected a juror was guilty of bias, fraud or an offence related to the person's involvement in the jury's performance.

Justice Atkinson said she was concerned enlivening the subsection could drive "a highway" through the confidentiality of the jury system and "then I don't see how we could continue the jury system".

But when she dismissed the application on Monday, she agreed not to publish her reasons on the Queensland courts website until the appeal process had expired.

The trio's lawyers said they would most likely appeal Justice Atkinson's decision on questioning the juror and indicated they would likely go to the Court of Appeal over the murder convictions.

The Bjelke-Petersen 1991 perjury trial, which was deadlocked with a hung jury, became infamous when it was revealed the jury foreman was a member of the Young Nationals and was identified with the Friends of Joh movement.

Topics:  jury, mark dempsey knight, murder, supreme court




Join the Community.

Get your local news, your way.

Stay Connected

Update your news preferences and get the latest news delivered to your inbox.

Apple’s new rose gold laptop

Sick of your standard silver Macbook?

How to keep cut flowers for longer

Bouquet mixed bouquet flowers

What to do with those gifts of flowers

Future Diamond finds welcome home in QLD

BUDDING STAR: Junior netballer Sarahpheinna Woulf is one of seven under-17 Queensland athletes selected in the Australian Diamonds emerging netball squad.

Junior netball star named in emerging Diamonds squad

Latest deals and offers

Man thanks colleagues for saving his life after forklift incident

Bruce O'Grady returned to his Wulkuraka workplace on Thursday to thank his workmates that saved his life after a workplace accident in January. (clockwise from left) Trent Court, Chris Aiken, Dale Ward and Scott Blackwell.

Ipswich paramedics have praised the workplace health and safety focus of a local...

RACQ releases SE Qld's worst choke points

Paul Turner, RACQ

Paul Turner from RACQ talks about our worst roads at peak time.

British family bashed in Thailand

Family beaten and kicked unconscious by gang in Thailand.

Family beaten and kicked unconscious by gang in Thailand.

Demand for acreage lots pushes up property prices

Property values in Cooroy have increased 25%

Property values jump in Cooroy and Peachester.

How a sacked real estate agent made $725k in four months

Agent is now under investigation by the industry watchdog

RBA warns of future apartment oversupply

Toowoomba: Crest Apartments and Burke & Wills, Ruthven Street ( view from Neil Street) Photo Bev Lacey / The Chronicle

RBA says oversupply of apartments poses risk to household finances