News

Coast specialist defends Jayant Patel's decision to operate

Jayant Patel
Jayant Patel Dave Hunt

A SUNSHINE Coast gastroenterologist testified he was not giving Jayant Patel "an out" as he defended the former Bundaberg surgeon's decision to operate on an elderly Bagara man.

Dr Johan van den Bogaerde, who works in Nambour, said waiting for Mervyn Morris to experience further rectal bleeding and become haemodynamically unstable would have resulted in a more complex surgery.

Dr van den Bogaerde, an expert witness in Patel's defence case in Brisbane Supreme Court on Monday, said there was no sign of an underlying chronic liver disease, heart problems or other issues that could have precluded surgery.

"I think one would probably call this a non-elective surgery," he said.

"Elective surgery would be something like a hip replacement in a patient with hip pain.

"Non-elective surgery would be a patient that had actually broken their hip and needed the operation urgently.
"In this case there was an acute bleed … and the assumption was made quite reasonably that this was a diverticular bleed.

"On the basis of that surgery was decided upon.

Dr van den Bogaerde said the difficulty crept in when it came to the timing of this non-elective surgery.

He said there was usually only a small window of opportunity to perform the surgery while the patient was in a "fairly stable state".

"Surgeons have to make decisions about when is the best time to operate and that makes surgery extraordinarily difficult," he said.

"There's an axiom about surgery that says a good surgeon knows how to operate, the better surgeon knows when to operate but the best surgeon knows when not to operate.

"The critical issue about surgery is to operate when the patient is in the best physiological state for the operation but not to operate a day or two or a week later when the patient has collapsed or something has made him in a worse physiological state."

Crown prosecutor David Meredith questioned whether Patel should have seen signs of radiation proctitis when he did a colonoscopy on May 2, a few weeks before the surgery.

When Dr van den Bogaerde agreed, he suggested the only inference that could be drawn was that Patel did not do a colonoscopy.

"No there's another inference that can be drawn that the radiation proctitis was so mild that it wasn't endoscopically apparent and that would fit a lot better with the clinical course of this patient," the doctor said.
Mr Meredith suggested that answer was "allowing Dr Patel an out".

"I'm not here to allow anyone an out, I'm just here to give my opinion, sir," Dr van den Bogaerde said.

The doctor said he, personally, had recommended surgery for only 10 to 15 patients with diverticular bleeding in the past 10 years.

Dr van den Bogaerde said he worked closely with surgeons but his recommendations were just that, with surgeons making the ultimate decision.

The trial continues.

Topics:  brisbane supreme court, bundaberg base hospital, crime, jayant patel, manslaughter




Truck leaves an "offal" mess on road

Offal littered the Warrego Highway near Kholo on Monday afternoon. Photo: Rob Williams / The Queensland Times

Motorists encounter smelly road obstruction

Struggling country shows get major boost

Callum Mack, 6 and Joe Murray, 6, at the Rosewood Show. Photo Inga Williams / The Queensland Times

Three local show societies helped by State Government funding

7 times shonky businessman made headlines

LIFE OF RILEY: While Ipswich pensioners have been left thousands of dollars out of pocket the man behind IpswichPatios and Sheds is living the high life in Loganholme.

Former Ipswich shed man up to old tricks

Latest deals and offers

Rob Kardashian 'neglected' by Blac Chyna

Friends say they are now 'back in love'

Isla Fisher: I don't like talking about my private life

Isla Fisher shut down TV hosts when they asked about her husband

Mariah Carey: I 'can't believe' Prince has gone

'Prince was one of the best people I've met'

Joe Jonas' 'tough' pals

Joe Jonas' pals are 'tough' with his potential partners

The Bachelor wash up: bacon, plank offs and that white rose

Richie Strahan, second from left, with bachelorettes Eliza, Faith, Noni and Janey in a scene from episode one of the fourth season of The Bachelor.

RICHIE Strahan meets some beautiful, and colourful, bachelorettes.

Town with 'unique country flair' will be ruined: resident

Jonathan Emms of Rosewood is concerned about a proposed townhouse development for this John Street block of land.

Residents concerned by high density development proposal

You can own this Queensland town for just $1

Yelarbon

Unprecedented auction of town's business centre with no reserve

Work starts on $15M Caloundra apartment building

Turning the first sod at the Aqua View Apartments site in Kings Beach are (from left) husband-and-wife developers Alex Yuan and Stella Sun with construction company Tomkins director Mike Tomkins and Councillor Tim Dwyer.

Developers excited about addition to Kings Beach skyline

72-year-old Coast developer set to start new project

GREEN LIGHT: The Cosmopolitan has been approved for development at Cotton Tree.

Meet the Canberran set to deliver another chapter for Coast suburb

Plans revealed for 1500-lot 'master-planned community'

Precinct will be bounded by Boundary St and Shoesmith Rd