Bid for Patel's manslaughter charge to be put on hold rejected

Former Bundaberg surgeon Jayant Patel
Former Bundaberg surgeon Jayant Patel Dave Hunt

DR JAYANT Patel will face trial early next year for manslaughter after he lost his bid to have the criminal charge permanently stayed.

In handing down his decision regarding the former Bundaberg surgeon's application, Supreme Court Justice George Fryberg took a swipe at the prosecution for providing incomplete and embarrassing particulars as part of their case.

In a written judgment delivered on Thursday, Justice Fryberg stated particulars were supposed to inform an opponent and a trial judge about the detail a party relied on and to adhere to their particularised case.

"The deficiencies in these particulars mean they do not achieve that objective," he said.

"There is a need for the prosecution to identify precisely what its case is, to work out which of its allegations stand alone (if any) and which act in conjunction..."

Justice Fryberg said the particulars put forward were "incomplete and embarrassing" and revealed there were even further deficiencies that he saw no point delving into.

"It is not the function of the trial judge to write the prosecution's particulars for it; I say no more," he stated.

Dr Patel is scheduled to face trial for the manslaughter of Mervyn Morris, 75, at Bundaberg Base Hospital in June 2003.

The Crown alleges Dr Patel was negligent in ordering Mr Morris undergo an operation.

Mr Morris died in post-operative care after surgery.

In their application for the manslaughter charge to be permanently stayed, Dr Patel's legal team argued the Crown planned to use matters abandoned in Patel's first manslaughter trial.

A High Court quashed Patel's conviction earlier this year and the Director of Public Prosecutions subsequently ordered a retrial.

Justice Fryberg ordered some of the Crown's particulars be struck out.

He stated the Crown should state when it alleges the incorrect diagnosis was made and particularise what investigations into the condition of Mr Morris's liver should have been carried out.

Justice Fryberg ordered the Crown file "proper particulars" before January 11.

He dismissed Patel's application for a permanent stay.

Topics:  crime, jayant patel, manslaughter charge, supreme court



Local Real Estate

finda logo
Featured Real Estate
LARGE 4 BEDROOM HIGHSET... $339,000 NEG
House 4 2 4
INVESTOR ALERT! $239,000
House 3 1 1
FOR SALE OR LEASE ... For Lease...
Commercial * Lease at only $67 per m2 +OGs + GST - Sale ...
Zengarra $849,000
Commercial Basking in the grandeur of Mt Greville, on approx. 73 acres in ...

Featured Jobs

finda logo

Ipswich jobs listed daily

Featured Jobs
GENERAL MANAGER ... Gladstone Full Time $120 - $150
SHORT ORDER COOK Walloon Casual
Team Leader Ipswich Full Time


Local Partners

LATEST DEALS AND OFFERS

Job Listings

Search for your next job now.
Learn More

Cars For Sale

Find cars for sale online now.
Learn More

Property Listings

Search for a property online right now.
Learn More

Local Profile

Stay Connected

Get the news as it happens, in your inbox

You can change the newsletters you are subscribed to when you edit your profile

Edit Profile


Special Offers

Latest deals and offers

View today's ePaper!

Read the digital edition
Learn More

Horoscopes

Virgo

Your dreams are vivid, and there may be some psychic experiences that will help you come to a conclusion over a problem. Trust your instincts.

read more

Marketplace

Special Offers & Promotions

Compare & Save