News

Bid for Patel's manslaughter charge to be put on hold rejected

Former Bundaberg surgeon Jayant Patel
Former Bundaberg surgeon Jayant Patel Dave Hunt

DR JAYANT Patel will face trial early next year for manslaughter after he lost his bid to have the criminal charge permanently stayed.

In handing down his decision regarding the former Bundaberg surgeon's application, Supreme Court Justice George Fryberg took a swipe at the prosecution for providing incomplete and embarrassing particulars as part of their case.

In a written judgment delivered on Thursday, Justice Fryberg stated particulars were supposed to inform an opponent and a trial judge about the detail a party relied on and to adhere to their particularised case.

"The deficiencies in these particulars mean they do not achieve that objective," he said.

"There is a need for the prosecution to identify precisely what its case is, to work out which of its allegations stand alone (if any) and which act in conjunction..."

Justice Fryberg said the particulars put forward were "incomplete and embarrassing" and revealed there were even further deficiencies that he saw no point delving into.

"It is not the function of the trial judge to write the prosecution's particulars for it; I say no more," he stated.

Dr Patel is scheduled to face trial for the manslaughter of Mervyn Morris, 75, at Bundaberg Base Hospital in June 2003.

The Crown alleges Dr Patel was negligent in ordering Mr Morris undergo an operation.

Mr Morris died in post-operative care after surgery.

In their application for the manslaughter charge to be permanently stayed, Dr Patel's legal team argued the Crown planned to use matters abandoned in Patel's first manslaughter trial.

A High Court quashed Patel's conviction earlier this year and the Director of Public Prosecutions subsequently ordered a retrial.

Justice Fryberg ordered some of the Crown's particulars be struck out.

He stated the Crown should state when it alleges the incorrect diagnosis was made and particularise what investigations into the condition of Mr Morris's liver should have been carried out.

Justice Fryberg ordered the Crown file "proper particulars" before January 11.

He dismissed Patel's application for a permanent stay.

Topics:  crime, jayant patel, manslaughter charge, supreme court




Stay Connected

Update your news preferences and get the latest news delivered to your inbox.

Having battled PND four times, Mel says the secret is sleep

'I just thought, don’t all mothers get no sleep?’

'My husband lasted 6 weeks as a stay at home dad'

APN Hey Mummy Feature for online - stock images. Katie Dykes being interviewed for the webisodes. Photo Marc Stapelberg / The Northern Star

FROM the outside, being a stay at home mum looks like a breeze.

THE EXPERT: Stop judging working mothers

SUPER MUMS: Being a working mums comes down to perfecting time management.

"WORKING for money is all right; so is working because you want to.”

Health and nutrition with kids - how do you balance it?

HOW important is health and nutrition in your household?

Smack or no smack - where do you stand?

THE debate is reignited - is smacking acceptable?

Technology and kids: Do you ever cut their wi-fi?

Check out our new video series featuring mums having a chat

Council dumps higher charges on residents

RISING PRICES: Eastern Heights resident Dave Clark says if the council should towards a user pays system to cover the cost of dumps instead of “sneaking” prices up gradually.

From August 1 residents will pay $10

Vow to unite Ipswich with NBN

CATCH UP: Blair incumbent Shayne Neumann wants to get Labor’s NBN back on track if Bill Shorten wins government.

Candidates debate fibre to the node or fibre to home

Latest deals and offers

Clive Palmer to re-open refinery

Clive Palmer on ABC radio.

Clive Palmer talks about his achievements, election chances and re-opening the...

Dr Ian MacDonald

Dr Ian MacDonald gets the all clear to retire from Brassall Medical Clinic staff Larissa Meldrum and Linda Davey.

Dr Ian MacDonald

Vox Pop: Council's rate increase

Mayor Paul Pisasale.

Members of the public speak out on Ipswich City Council's rate increase.

Arts and culture get a boost in council budget

HAPPY CAMPER: Council’s culture boss Cr Charlie Pisasale will be delighted $400,000 has been allocated for a business case investigation for IPAC.

IPAC at the forefront of councillor's agenda

Burnett Heads housing development approved

COUNCIL APPROVED: A Burnett Heads housing development has been approved by Bundaberg Regional Council. Photo Contributed

Councillors approved the development seven votes to four